What is the cause of the failure of this staircase?

Considering structural design and detailing standards, what do you think is the cause of the failure of this staircase?


Read also…
Comparative analysis of staircase using Staad Pro and manual calculation
Design of sawtooth (slabless staircase)
Structural analysis of free standing staircase
Design of reinforced concrete staircase

Write your answer in the comment section. Thank you very much.

12 COMMENTS

  1. There are no distribution and top bars returning from the landing. That is the most likely cause of this failure in my opinion.

  2. Wrong detailing of reinforcements. The reinforcements from the flight ought to act as top bars at landing. While those from the landing will act as top at the face of flight forming a scissors-like shape

  3. The way I see it, this failure probably resulted from just the dead load of the stair. To bad!
    Probable causes;
    i. No top rebar to resist shearing stress especially at that end where high stress is expected.
    I. Absence of distribution bars
    iii.The waist might be insufficient considering the span.

  4. What I could deduce here is wrong detailing which is not limited to: 1. Lack of distribution bars.
    2. No top bars to resist shear i.e. cranking of flight bottom bars to become top bars and vice versa. Also no provision of extra bars to connect the resulted flight and landing top rebars.

  5. # Reinforcement placement is wrong @ support.
    # And may be concrete was poured in 2 different sequence with no bonding between old and new

  6. Lack of continuity rebars at the location of failure. This has limited the effective depth resisting shear and moment at the location to the concrete cover which has triggered shear failure sInce d is too small.
    A more general answer is poor detailing.

  7. vertical shear force caused current damage. Section shear capacity is not enough what can be seen in lack of shear reinforcement around longitudal rods also.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here